Three Truths. And a Lie
Perhaps it’s just me.
But, meeting bright young leaders makes me feel terribly, terribly old.
Particularly when their children are now the same age they were…
when I first taught them, or looked after them, as toddlers.
Grooaan.
Wendy and I met such a one again this Tuesday.
Someone we’d known since she was still in Primary school.
Now, she’s a well-respected scientist. Naturally.
And a talented, stridently confident, youth leader in West Sussex.
The theme of Tuesday evening’s Youth Activity was ‘Three Truths and a Lie’
Rather like the BBC One show ‘Would I Lie to You’.
Greeting her, I said, “Am I allowed to hear the lie you’ve prepared, when it’s your turn.”
To which she promptly replied, with a grin on her face…
“Oh Hello! Well, I must say… how nice it is to see you again!”
Touche!
I remember meeting such a confident leader in a Workshop some time ago.
He had succeeded in not only being financially and commercially successful.
His firm also enjoyed a measure of influence amongst financial planners across the country.
Others spoke of his leadership as being courageous and determined.
Those qualities seemed to have served him magnificently.
His business was much admired.
That much was true.
Except now, mixing with his peers for the day… his confidence manifested as something else.
A quiet condescension.
An aroma that wafted amongst the questions he posed to others during the day.
Questions that got them dancing to his tune; his views on business and life.
Meanwhile, I noticed him quietly, humbly, handing out counsel, whenever someone raised a painful problem they were wrestling with as a boutique firm leader.
Wise counsel. That’s true.
Yet counsel that was never, actually, asked for.
What happened then was fascinating.
The person receiving that confident, beautifully articulated counsel… halted. Looked puzzled. Went quiet. Looked down at their hands.
And it was a few seconds before they seemed to collect their thoughts… and, stumbling, tried to get back to what they were saying.
I felt my skin prickling.
Something about this felt disturbingly familiar.
The scene unfolded more than once that day.
Their thinking was paying the price for someone else’s generously shared confidence-through-success.
What haunted me then was that I was no longer looking at him.
I felt I was looking at me.
I’d seen this scene before… and not in this Workshop.
And in that moment, a fresh truth came home to roost.
My years devoted to helping leaders to think.
To championing their ability to listen to their teams and clients.
Years teaching the importance of allowing others to discover their own answers.
And yet…
And yet.
My own sentences of counsel and advice echoed across the years…
as I watched this Workshop day play out.
And that was true, too.
Painfully true.
Perhaps that’s the lie we tell ourselves.
That because our people listen to us…
They must be growing.
And I find myself wondering…
How many times have I watched someone fall silent.
A client.
A colleague.
Someone whose thinking I believed I was helping to liberate.
Without ever realising…
It was me.
My wisdom.
My generously offered counsel.
Me.
I had silenced their thinking.
